I was expecting something better out of this lip balm. The smell up close is very nice, however when swiped on the lips it tastes like perfume. For a lip product it's terrible because all u get to taste is perfume and not cookie at all. The perfume taste also transfers into the cups you're drinking in. The packaging is cute and convenient for small bags but the performance is not what is promised. Something is definitely wrong with the formula. It's very disappointing.